Managing OTC confirmations by hand creates hidden costs across risk, compliance and operations. Manual work persists because complex confirmations arrive unstructured and existing systems aren’t connected. Firms can cut these costs by fixing their data first, then automating how confirmations are extracted, matched and chased.
Every OTC trade ends with two firms agreeing, in writing, on exactly what they’ve traded. That confirmation becomes the record that risk, P&L, collateral and settlement all depend on, so if it’s wrong, everything downstream is wrong too.
However, many firms still re-key and chase complex OTC confirmations by hand.
The costs of these manual processes are easy to miss because they never arrive as a single bill. They arrive in instalments: a booking error that surfaces days later, a missed confirmation deadline, teams working late at month-end to clear the backlog.
So why, with so much technology in place, are confirmations still such hard work? And what can firms do about it?
OTC confirmations still rely on manual work because complex trades arrive as unstructured documents that systems can’t read, and because the systems firms already have aren’t connected into one process.
Booking systems, matching platforms and market utility connections are standard at most firms. Yet confirmations teams still spend much of their day re-keying and chasing. There are two main reasons why.
First, those systems run on structured data, and complex OTC confirmations rarely arrive that way. They turn up as long-form PDFs and emails, each in the counterparty’s own format, with economic terms and legal clauses written out in prose. Template-based tools can’t cope when every counterparty does things differently and formats keep changing. When a system can’t read a document, a person has to.
Second, each system does its own job well, but nothing ties them together. A matching platform can compare trade data, but someone has to get the data there first and deal with whatever it flags. That usually means someone keying data from one system into another, tracking status in a spreadsheet and following up by email. The irony is that every new system can add another gap for people to fill.
The main hidden costs of manual OTC confirmations are errors that spread to downstream systems, missed regulatory deadlines and pressure on operations teams.
A single mistyped digit doesn’t stay small for long. When trade details are keyed in by hand, it’s easy to slip on the notional, a date, a rate or a fixing source. Often nobody notices until the wrong terms are already sitting in every system that relies on the trade.
Then the clean-up begins. Figures get restated, margin calls get disputed, payments go out wrong and regulatory reports need amending. The trade goes back to the front office to be rebooked, then through confirmation and matching all over again, on a deal everyone thought was finished.
Regulators set tight deadlines for confirming OTC derivatives, and manual processes struggle to meet them. Under the European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR), most uncleared trades between financial firms must be confirmed by the end of the next business day. UK EMIR applies the same rule, and Dodd-Frank sets similar deadlines in the US. When a busy day hits and confirmations depend on people working through an inbox, those deadlines are the first thing to slip.
Then there’s the evidence. If a regulator asks who confirmed a trade and when, the answer shouldn’t involve digging through email chains and shared drives. European regulators have already fined firms for failing to confirm on time and for lacking processes to monitor confirmation deadlines.
Trading volumes keep rising. Operations teams often don’t. The extra work lands on the people already there, and experienced staff end up spending their days on routine checks a system could handle, when they could be investigating exceptions or improving how the team works.
It also makes the process fragile. Knowing how each counterparty formats its confirmations, or which terms it usually pushes back on, often sits in a few people’s heads. When one of them is off sick or moves on, confirmations slow down and mistakes creep in.
A good OTC confirmations process gives teams clear visibility of outstanding trades, proof of agreement with every counterparty, a full audit trail and clean, consistent trade data.
Defining this before choosing any new tool gives firms something to measure their current process against. In practice, it means:
That last item is usually the one to fix first. When the data is wrong, confirmations break. Counterparty details go out of date. Settlement instructions don’t match. A trade gets booked with different terms in two systems. Put automation on top of that, and the same breaks keep coming back, only faster.
Xceptor automates OTC confirmations by validating trade data as it arrives, extracting details from any confirmation format and matching them against the firm’s books, while connecting to the systems firms already use.
It starts with the data. Every trade is checked as it enters the process, so problems are caught before they reach matching or downstream systems. And because Xceptor connects to the booking systems, matching platforms and market utilities firms already use, there’s nothing to rip out or replace.
For inbound confirmations, Xceptor’s Confirmations Agent reads each counterparty document in any format, with no templates or OCR. It classifies the document by asset class and trade type, extracts the trade economics and key legal clauses, and flags anything missing. From there, Xceptor offers:
Firms should start by identifying where confirmations still depend on re-keying, chasing or manual comparison, because those steps are where automation makes the biggest difference.
This doesn’t need a huge transformation programme. Three questions are enough to map where the manual effort sits:
The answers show which areas are slowing confirmations down most. From there, the next step is to bring them into a connected, automated workflow. More trades can go straight through, and teams only step in for the exceptions that need their judgement.
Ready to see where automation could make the biggest difference to your confirmations process? Get in touch with the Xceptor team.
What is an OTC confirmation?
An OTC confirmation is the written record two counterparties agree on after an over-the-counter trade. It sets out the trade’s economic terms, such as notional, dates and rates, along with any legal terms. Risk, P&L, collateral and settlement systems all rely on it being accurate.
What are the EMIR timely confirmation requirements?
EMIR requires OTC derivatives that aren’t centrally cleared to be confirmed within set deadlines. Where both counterparties are financial firms, or non-financial firms above the clearing threshold, trades must be confirmed by the end of the next business day. Smaller non-financial firms have slightly longer. UK EMIR applies equivalent rules.
Why are OTC confirmations so hard to automate?
Complex OTC trades are often bespoke, and confirmations arrive as long-form PDFs and emails in each counterparty’s own format. Template-based tools struggle with this variation. Existing systems also tend to handle one step each, leaving people to move data between them.
Can AI help automate OTC confirmations?
Yes. AI is most useful with unstructured documents, such as extracting trade economics and legal clauses from a counterparty’s confirmation. Xceptor’s Confirmations Agent does this without templates and gives a confidence score for each extraction. Matching then runs on defined rules, and people review the exceptions.
How can firms reduce the cost of manual OTC confirmations?
Start by finding where trade details are still re-keyed, where counterparties are chased by hand and where terms are compared manually. Fix the data behind those steps, then bring them into a connected, automated workflow so teams only handle the exceptions.